V1 Current-Tip Independent Verdict (Engineering Assessment + Human Pointer)¶
Status: GO_DEMO_RC (human-signed for bounded demo RC; this file remains engineering pointer)
Date: 2026-08-26 (refreshed after V1F-002 DONE + V1F-001/003 SIGNED)
Auditor (this draft): AI engineering assessment — not a substitute for signed human files
Human signed verdicts:
- V1-current-tip-human-verdict-20260826.md — SIGNED GO_DEMO_RC
- T6B2-independent-verdict-20260826.md — SIGNED PASS
Handoff: ../execution/V1-HUMAN-AUDITOR-HANDOFF-V1F-003.md — SIGNED
Production authorization: NONE
CERTIFIED (production baseline): NO
Superseding adversarial audit: V1-remediation-20260826-independent-audit.md
T6B2 engineering re-verification: T6B2-engineering-reverification-20260826.md (ENGINEERING_ONLY)
Summary¶
Exact pair FE f7a20f7d… + BE 6ef1aa46… (tree 8bef7a61…) has green engineering rebind pass counts; demo DB remediated (V1F-004); production FE bleed restored (V1F-007); isolation FE immutability hardened (V1F-008). Demo UAT 16/16 after V1F-002 SPMB leaf-controller shadow fix. Human sign-off records GO_DEMO_RC for QG-18 documentation freeze on the bounded demo candidate path. Production remains NO-GO. CERTIFIED remains NO.
Served demo identities (verified 2026-08-26 post V1F-002)¶
| Surface | Commit / build | Match candidate |
|---|---|---|
| Demo FE | f7a20f7d… · fe-build-f7a20f7d-v1demo · path under /var/www/scola-releases/demo/ |
YES |
| Demo BE | 6ef1aa46… · tree 8bef7a61… |
YES |
| Demo DB | scoladev_demo UUID fad7c305-… |
YES |
| Production FE (restore) | 1ffc7160… · fe-build-1ffc7160a652-rc11repro |
Restore baseline (not demo candidate) |
Findings¶
| ID | Severity | Finding | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| V1F-001 | S2 | T6B/T6B.2 independent human verdict | SIGNED_GO |
| V1F-002 | S2 | Demo UAT SPMB admin registers Access denied | DONE — UAT 16/16 |
| V1F-003 | S3 | Human independent auditor review | SIGNED_GO |
| V1F-004 | S2 | Demo DB stuck modules + cron skip | REMEDIATED |
| V1F-005 | S2 | Stale rebind SHA | REMEDIATED (pass counts); W03 → V1F-009 |
| V1F-006 | S3 | Prefix parity optional FAIL 4/4 | OPEN |
| V1F-007 | S0 | Production FE bleed | REMEDIATED |
| V1F-008 | S2 | Isolation FE bleed false confidence | REMEDIATED |
| V1F-009 | S3 | W03 evidence missing SHA/tree | OPEN — full harness plan only |
| V1F-010 | S2 | HTTP worker DB-connect flakiness | OPEN — prod restart deferred |
Engineering / human verdict¶
GO_DEMO_RC for bounded demo / release-candidate engineering path (human-authorized chat 2026-08-26).
NO-GO for CERTIFIED production baseline / production promote / V1F-010 production restart.
Do not use this file as production promotion authority.