Lewati ke isi

T4/W05 Independent Findings

Finding Severity Independent code review Independent runtime proof Evidence integrity Verdict Residual
W05-F-001 session/day binding S0 Forged sheet is rejected unless session and local date match Independent matrix: W05-TEACHER-FORGED-SHEET and foreign-session cases PASS Current-tip matrix and E1.2 validator PASS CLOSED_BY_INDEPENDENT_AUDIT None observed
W05-F-002 roster/tenant scope S0 Student membership, company and session ownership are checked before writes Foreign student/session and cross-tenant cases PASS; DB persistence assertions unchanged Current Golden runtime bound to BE tip CLOSED_BY_INDEPENDENT_AUDIT None observed
W05-F-003 teacher ACL/elevation S0 Direct RPC remains normal ACL-denied; API elevation is scoped after authorization Independent W05-RPC-TEACHER-CREATE-LINE PASS with no row created; authorized save PASS Runtime matrix includes both paths CLOSED_BY_INDEPENDENT_AUDIT None observed
W05-F-004 portal peer isolation/proof privacy S0 Student-own-line rule and parent serializer stripping are present Parent peer denied; student peer RPC exposes no peer; own flows succeed Matrix plus source review CLOSED_BY_INDEPENDENT_AUDIT None observed
W05-F-005 concurrency/idempotency S1 Unique sheet constraint and session/date lookup prevent duplicate sheets Concurrent save produced one success, one uniqueness failure, one sheet/line DB state asserted CLOSED_BY_INDEPENDENT_AUDIT None observed
W05-F-006 operational upgrade S2 New rule requires module upgrade on non-Golden tenant DBs Golden is upgraded; other tenant upgrade not part of this audit Deployment prerequisite documented DOWNSTREAM_OPERATIONAL_PREREQUISITE Run -u scola_attendance per tenant before rollout