Lewati ke isi

T3/W02 Independent Findings

Finding Severity Independent code review Independent runtime proof Evidence integrity Verdict Residual
T3W02-F-001 parent tenant scope S0 No-existing-parent branch in parent_admin_api.py:437-482 omits partner scope validation before Parent.create Company-20 admin successfully linked company-22 partner to company-20 student; relation and response were observed, then fixture was removed Bound live request and DB-created relation NOT_FIXED Cross-tenant parent/identity mutation remains possible
T3W02-F-002 served FE identity binding S1 E1.2 validator checks manifest versus dist version but not served commit versus certified FE application commit dist/version.json served a333a8f2...; certified W02 FE application commit is b144cf78...; app files changed between these commits Validator PASS is false-green for this mismatch NOT_FIXED Rebuild/rebind and strengthen validator binding before relying on FE evidence
T3W02-F-003 W02 denominator gap S2 Existing matrix covers existing relation updates but not creation with a foreign partner lacking op.parent Independent probe exposed the missing case 32/32 does not cover this adversarial branch NOT_FIXED Add explicit foreign-partner/no-existing-parent case after remediation